Omaha's Best New York Style Pizza [Updated 2025]

After scouring the city and indulging in slice after glorious slice, I’ve reviewed a dozen top pizza joints that promise to transport your taste buds straight to the bustling streets of New York. With each bite, I’ve savored the crispy crust, the tangy sauce, and the gooey cheese, meticulously noting what makes each pizzeria unique.

You might be wondering why you should trust my pizza palate. Well, let’s just say I’ve become a bit of a pizza connoisseur, sampling everything from the classic pepperoni to inventive toppings. So grab a napkin and get ready; together we’re about to dive into a savory adventure that will leave you craving a slice of Omaha’s finest!

Noli's Pizzeria - Blackstone

Highlights
Crispy, airy pizza crust
Balanced toppings and flavors
Popular Blackstone location
Exciting dining atmosphere
Inconsistency in service

Noli's Pizzeria in the bustling Blackstone district is a delightful destination for lovers of New York style pizza. As I stepped inside, I was immediately greeted by an exciting dining atmosphere that vibrantly echoed New York City’s energy. The crispy, airy pizza crust impressed me right from the start; each bite was perfectly chewy yet wonderfully crisp, which is no easy feat.

Their pizzas boast a well-balanced medley of toppings that meld beautifully without overwhelming the palate. From the classic Margherita to the more adventurous specialty pies, the flavors felt authentic and inviting, allowing me to savor a slice of the Big Apple right here in Omaha.

However, my visit wasn’t without its hiccups. I experienced a touch of inconsistency in service, which is a small caveat in what was otherwise a delightful dining experience. Still, the flavorful pies and lively atmosphere made it easy to overlook that minor detail.

All in all, Noli's Pizzeria - Blackstone brings a taste of New York that’s difficult to resist. If you’re in the mood for pizza that’ll transport you to the streets of NYC, this is definitely a must-visit spot!

You might also want to check out the best pizza in Omaha.

Dolomiti | Pizzeria & Enoteca

Highlights
Thin and nice dough
Lively and cozy atmosphere
Friendly and efficient service
Variety of delicious dishes
Crispy and cheesy zucca pizza

Dolomiti | Pizzeria & Enoteca has quickly become one of my favorite stops in Omaha when it comes to satisfying that craving for authentic New York-style pizza. From the moment I stepped inside, I was greeted by a lively and cozy atmosphere that immediately set the tone for an enjoyable evening.

I decided to indulge in their crispy zucca pizza, which features a perfectly thin crust that’s both crispy and cheesy. Each bite revealed a delightful symphony of flavors, showcasing the quality of their dough. It's the kind of crust that makes you feel like you’ve been transported straight to a bustling New York pizzeria.

What truly stood out was the friendly and efficient service. The staff were not only knowledgeable about the menu but also genuinely passionate about their craft, which made the experience all the more enjoyable. Dolomiti offers a variety of delicious dishes, but the pizza stole the show for me.

If you’re in Omaha and seeking a slice of New York-style heaven, look no further than Dolomiti. It’s a splendid blend of quality, taste, and atmosphere that’s sure to keep you coming back for more!

You might also want to check out the best brunch in Omaha.

Don Carmelo's Pizzeria

Highlights
Best pizza in Omaha
Tons of toppings available
Perfect crust and sauce
Foldable NY style slices
Owner-made pizzas are superior

Don Carmelo's Pizzeria in Omaha truly serves up some of the best pizza in the city. Upon stepping inside, I was greeted by the tantalizing aroma of freshly baked dough, which promised a slice of New York right in the heart of Nebraska. What struck me most was the perfect crust—golden and crisp yet soft enough to fold, just as a true NY slice should be.

Their sauce is a delightful balance of tangy and savory, providing a flavorful backdrop for the tons of toppings available. Whether you're a classic pepperoni lover or adventurous with gourmet options, Don Carmelo’s satisfies every craving. I opted for a half-and-half pizza, showcasing the variety that keeps pizza lovers returning for more. Each slice was generously loaded and folded beautifully for easy handling—key for that authentic New York experience.

The pizza is primarily owner-made, which adds a personal touch that can be tasted in every bite. Overall, if you’re in Omaha and in the mood for New York style pizza, Don Carmelo’s is a must-try—an experience that charms as much as it satisfies!

You might also want to check out the best hamburgers in Omaha.

DANTE

Highlights
Delicious, flavorful pizzas
Fantastic crust and toppings
Perfectly cooked pasta
Half-price happy hour daily
Rich and irresistible Buddino

At DANTE, the art of crafting New York style pizza reaches delicious new heights. As soon as I stepped into the lively atmosphere, I was welcomed with the enticing aroma of fresh basil and bubbling cheese. The pizza offerings are nothing short of exceptional. The crust is wonderfully crispy yet chewy, a fantastic base for the flavor-packed toppings that are meticulously chosen.

I couldn't resist indulging in their signature pies, each one a testament to the culinary expertise that defines this local gem. On top of their pizza prowess, DANTE also offers perfectly cooked pasta that complimented my meal beautifully. However, what truly captured my heart was their Buddino; this rich dessert was the perfect way to end my meal—a sweet finish to a delightful dining experience.

Bonus points go to their half-price happy hour deal, which adds an irresistible charm to the overall dining experience. DANTE has undoubtedly earned its place among the best in Omaha's pizza scene, and if you haven't yet had the pleasure of indulging here, you're truly missing out. Trust me, your taste buds will thank you for it!

You might also want to check out the best donuts in Omaha.

Noli's Pizzeria - Aksarben

Highlights
Live music on Wednesdays
Beautifully cooked pizza crust
Great topping selection
Fun and lively atmosphere
Friendly and knowledgeable bartenders

I had the pleasure of diving into a slice of heaven at Noli's Pizzeria - Aksarben, and let me tell you, it was nothing short of spectacular! As soon as I stepped inside, the lively atmosphere enveloped me like a warm hug. The place buzzed with energy, especially on Wednesdays when live music fills the air, adding to the enticing vibe.

Now, let's talk about the star of the show: the pizza. Taking a bite of their beautifully cooked crust felt like stepping into a pizzeria in New York City, with just the right amount of chewiness and a satisfying crunch. With a great topping selection, I indulged and mixed and matched flavors, all perfectly balanced atop that glorious foundation. Every ingredient felt fresh and meticulously chosen, making each slice a delightful experience.

To top it off, the friendly and knowledgeable bartenders elevated my meal with excellent drink pairings. If you're seeking a taste of New York-style pizza right here in Omaha, Noli's is an absolute must-visit. It’s more than just a pizzeria; it’s a slice of joy waiting to be savored!

You might also want to check out the best tacos in Omaha.

Williamsburg Pizza Omaha

At Williamsburg Pizza Omaha, I was greeted with a slice of Brooklyn nostalgia right in the heart of Nebraska. The crust? Perfectly crisp and flavorful, with just the right amount of chew—a true homage to the classic New York style. The sauce, rich and tangy, perfectly complemented the generous layers of gooey mozzarella. I indulged in their signature slice topped with fresh basil, giving it an elevated twist. The laid-back atmosphere truly made me feel at home. If you're seeking an authentic taste of New York, this spot is a must-visit. Grab a slice and enjoy! 🍕

You might also want to check out the best burgers in Omaha.

mootz

At mootz, I was immediately drawn in by the vibrant atmosphere and the delightful aroma of baking dough. The pizza was a true homage to New York style, with its perfectly crispy crust and generous toppings. Each slice boasted a delightful balance of rich tomato sauce and gooey mozzarella that made my palate dance. The authenticity isn’t just in the ingredients; it's in the passion of the team behind the counter. I savored every bite, leaving me yearning for more. If you’re on the hunt for a slice that satisfies, mootz is a must-visit destination in Omaha!

You might also want to check out the best coffee shops in Omaha.

Lyle's Pizzeria

Lyle's Pizzeria is a gem in Omaha's pizza scene! As I walked in, the aroma of melting cheese and fresh toppings enveloped me. I ordered a classic pepperoni slice, and let me tell you, the crust was a perfect balance of crispy and chewy—just like a true New York slice should be. The marinara sauce was rich and tangy, complementing the generous cheese layer beautifully. Each bite transported me to the bustling streets of NYC, which is no small feat! If you’re searching for authentic flavors and a lively atmosphere, Lyle's is an absolute must-try!

You might also want to check out the best mexican restaurants in Omaha.

Piezon's Pizzeria

Piezon's Pizzeria truly captures the essence of New York style pizza right here in Omaha. The moment I walked in, the aroma of fresh dough and zesty tomato sauce enveloped me, making it hard to resist. I opted for a classic pepperoni slice, and let me tell you, it was a perfect triangle of cheesy heaven! The crust was beautifully crispy yet foldable, just as a proper NY slice should be. Each bite burst with flavor, balancing the tanginess of the sauce and the richness of the cheese. This charming spot is a must-visit for any pizza lover! 🍕

You might also want to check out the best doughnuts in Omaha.

Virtuoso Pizzeria by David Losole

Walking into Virtuoso Pizzeria, I was greeted by the tantalizing aroma of melting cheese and freshly baked dough. The New York-style slices here are truly a work of art—thin, yet sturdy enough to hold a mountain of toppings. I savored the classic Margherita, where the sweet San Marzano tomatoes melded beautifully with creamy mozzarella and fragrant basil. Each bite transported me to the bustling streets of Manhattan. The friendly staff and cozy ambiance made it feel like home. If you're hunting for an authentic slice in Omaha, Virtuoso stands out as a must-try destination! 🍕

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in West Omaha.

Izzy's Pizza

Tucked away in the heart of Omaha, Izzy's Pizza is a delightful haven for pizza lovers. The moment I entered, the aroma of freshly baked dough and zesty sauce enveloped me like an old friend. I ordered a classic New York-style slice, and it did not disappoint! The crust was the perfect balance of crisp and chewy, while the cheese stretched delightfully with each bite. Topped with a rich marinara, it transported my taste buds straight to NYC! Overall, Izzy's is a must-visit for anyone craving an authentic slice that keeps you coming back for more! 🍕✨

You might also want to check out the best reuben sandwich in Omaha.

Smokin' Oak Wood-Fired Pizza and Taproom

Smokin' Oak Wood-Fired Pizza and Taproom is a delightful discovery in Omaha’s pizza scene. From the moment I stepped in, the aroma of wood-fired goodness enveloped me, promising a genuine New York experience. The crust was beautifully charred yet perfectly chewy, offering an ideal base for their rich tomato sauce and top-notch toppings. I opted for the classic Margherita, and every bite was a delicious reminder of why I adore NY-style pizza. With a vibrant atmosphere and a great selection of craft beers, it’s a slice of heaven that any pizza lover must try! 🍕✨

You might also want to check out the best bbq in Omaha.