Omaha's Best Pie [Updated 2025]

As I dove into the sweet and flaky world of pie, I put my taste buds to the test at twelve of Omaha's top pie spots. Each slice told a story, and trust me, I’ve eaten my fair share to bring you the cream of the crop.

Why should you take my word for it? I’ve savored pies from corner diners to cozy bakeries, and I’m not just about the hype—I’m all about that perfect crust and filling balance. Whether you crave classic fruit flavors or something a little quirky, I’ve got the inside scoop on where to satisfy your pie cravings in Omaha. Let’s embark on this delicious journey together!

Carter & Rye

Highlights
Flaky, delicious crusts
Unique and innovative flavors
Charming storefront ambiance
Limited but worthwhile hours
Savory and sweet options

Walking into Carter & Rye, I was immediately charmed by the cozy ambiance that this quaint spot offers. The first thing that struck me was the enchanting display of pies, each one seemingly whispering, “Pick me!” I simply couldn't resist.

I opted for a slice of their Blueberry Basil pie, and let me tell you—the moment I took a bite, it felt like a magical dance of flavors on my palate. The crust was the perfect balance of flaky and buttery, enveloping the juicy blueberries while the unexpected hint of basil added an exciting twist. This innovative flavor truly sets Carter & Rye apart in a city teeming with pie shops.

The menu is both savory and sweet, though it’s clear they specialize in pie artistry. While their hours are somewhat limited, the experience is undeniably worth the trip. If you’re in Omaha and seeking a slice of delight, don’t miss Carter & Rye. It’s a whimsical haven for pie lovers looking to explore uncharted flavor territories. Just remember to arrive early, as these pies disappear faster than you can say “slice of heaven!”

You might also want to check out the best seafood restaurants in Omaha.

WheatFields Eatery & Bakery

Highlights
Diverse dessert selection
Exceptional gluten-free options
Moist and flavorful baked goods
Great for family gatherings
Cozy atmosphere for conversations

Upon stepping into WheatFields Eatery & Bakery, I was immediately enveloped in a warm, inviting atmosphere that screamed "comfort." Walking past the tantalizing display of desserts, it felt like a joyous treasure hunt for pie lovers. My eyes were particularly drawn to the diverse dessert selection, showcasing an impressive lineup that promised something for everyone.

I decided to dive into their signature pie — a classic apple creation that had been lauded throughout the city. Every bite was a delightful explosion of moisture and flavor, the kind that leaves you wishing for more. What truly stood out, however, was their commitment to inclusivity; they offer exceptional gluten-free options that never compromise on taste, ensuring that everyone can join in on the fun.

As I savored my slice amidst the cozy ambiance, I couldn't help but envision how perfect this spot is for family gatherings. The chatter of conversations and laughter in the air only added to the charm. If you’re searching for a spot that blends familiarity with delightful surprises, look no further than WheatFields — a true gem in the Omaha pie scene!

You might also want to check out the best pizza in Omaha.

Sweet Magnolias Bake Shop

Highlights
Best bakery in Omaha
Amazing for special occasions
Gigantic, flavorful scones
Scrumptious cherry pie bars
Delightful tahini butterscotch bar

Sweet Magnolias Bake Shop has quickly become one of my favorite spots in Omaha for pie, but it has much more to offer. As I stepped inside, the sweet aroma of baked goods enveloped me like a cozy blanket. It’s the best bakery in Omaha, and it shows!

Now, let’s talk about the pies. Their cherry pie bars are simply to die for—each bite bursts with fruity sweetness that dances on your palate. I can genuinely say they defy the laws of pie-making! Not to be overlooked, the tahini butterscotch bar is also a delightful twist on traditional treats, offering a unique creamy texture that complements the rich butterscotch flavor beautifully.

Sweet Magnolias doesn’t just excel at pies; their gigantic scones are legendary as well, perfect for elevating any special occasion or simply satisfying your sweet tooth. Whether you're looking for a slice of heaven to brighten your day or planning for a gathering, this place has you covered with their delicious offerings.

In short, if you’re in Omaha and in search of the best pie experience with a touch of playfulness, Sweet Magnolias is a must-visit destination!

You might also want to check out the best brunch in Omaha.

Sweet Magnolias Bake & Cake Shop - Millwork

Highlights
Excellent customer service
Fabulous cinnamon rolls
Beautifully decorated cakes
Delicious flavor options
Highly recommended for desserts

Sweet Magnolias Bake & Cake Shop - Millwork is a delightful find in Omaha, where I indulged my sweet tooth and sought the best pie this city has to offer. Upon entering, the aroma of freshly baked goods welcomed me, setting the stage for a fantastical tasting adventure. The customer service here is as warm as the pastries; the staff greeted me with genuine smiles and impressive knowledge about their menu.

Now, let’s get to the heart of the matter — the pie! Each flavor option sparkled with potential, begging to be sampled. The classic apple pie stood out, boasting a flaky crust that perfectly cradled the spiced apple filling; every bite was a harmonious blend of sweetness and nostalgia.

While I savored the pie, I couldn’t resist trying one of their fabulous cinnamon rolls, known in the area as a must-try, and they did not disappoint! Beautifully decorated cakes also caught my eye, beckoning for future visits.

Overall, Sweet Magnolias is a charming gem in Omaha's bakery scene. If you’re on a quest for desserts that elevate your day, this spot is highly recommended! Trust me, your taste buds will be overjoyed!

You might also want to check out the best hamburgers in Omaha.

Conscious Comforts

Highlights
Outstanding gluten-free options
Pride in every made dish
Delicious seasonal treats
Quick communication & accommodation
Sweet and professional service

When I stepped into Conscious Comforts in Omaha, I was immediately struck by the warmth of the environment and the sweet aroma wafting from the kitchen. As someone who appreciates a slice of heavenly pie, I was thrilled to discover their outstanding gluten-free options. This remarkable place prides itself on crafting each dish with love, and their pies are no exception.

One bite of their seasonal pie, bursting with fresh, vibrant flavors, definitely brought a smile to my face. The crust was perfectly flaky, providing that ideal balance of texture beneath the luscious filling. I was genuinely impressed by how they managed to accommodate all dietary preferences without sacrificing taste.

Not only was the pie scrumptious, but the service was sweet and professional. The staff went above and beyond, ensuring that my questions about ingredients were answered with care and enthusiasm. I appreciated their quick communication — it made ordering an absolute breeze.

If you're in Omaha and have a hankering for a piece of pie bliss, be sure to visit Conscious Comforts. It's a delightful stop that will leave you smiling long after the last crumb is gone.

You might also want to check out the best donuts in Omaha.

SmallCakes Omaha

Highlights
Wedding cupcakes taste amazing
Seamless planning experience
Consistently fantastic flavors
Always exceeds expectations
Perfect for special occasions

SmallCakes Omaha has quickly become one of my favorite spots in the city, especially for their delightfully decadent cupcakes that transform my pie obsession into a sweet symphony. The moment I walked in, the atmosphere buzzed with creativity and warmth—a true testament to their seamless planning experience for special occasions.

What makes this place particularly stand out is how they juggle their cupcake artistry with flavors that dance on your palate. You might expect a bakery focused solely on cakes, but their pies pack a punch with consistently fantastic flavors that often exceed expectations. It’s not just about the taste; it’s about the experience as well. The staff is ever-so-friendly, which makes every visit feel like a celebration.

Though their wedding cupcakes are the stuff of legends, don't let that overshadow the perfect for special occasions pies they offer. Whether it's a slice of their rich chocolate or a fruit-filled delight, I find myself sifting through their offerings, entirely unsure of which to choose—because, quite frankly, I want them all! If you haven't yet visited SmallCakes Omaha, you are missing out on a pie experience that is nothing short of extraordinary!

You might also want to check out the best tacos in Omaha.

FarmHouse Cafe & Bakery

At FarmHouse Cafe & Bakery, pie perfection awaits! The moment I stepped inside, the heavenly aroma of freshly baked goods enveloped me. I decided on the classic cherry pie, and it was a delightful burst of flavor in every bite. The crust was flaky and golden, cradling the juicy, tart cherries beautifully. Each slice felt like a warm hug—comforting yet invigorating. The café’s cozy ambiance is the perfect backdrop for savoring this slice of heaven. If you’re on a quest for exceptional pie in Omaha, FarmHouse Cafe & Bakery is a must-visit destination! 🍰✨

You might also want to check out the best burgers in Omaha.

The Village PieMaker

Stepping into The Village PieMaker is like being wrapped in a warm, flaky hug. The quaint ambiance instantly transports you to a cozy kitchen filled with delightful aromas. I indulged in their signature cherry pie, and let me tell you, each bite was a burst of tart sweetness nestled in a perfectly golden crust. The balance of flavors was simply impeccable! I also appreciated their commitment to local ingredients, which shines through in every slice. If you're on a quest for exceptional pie, this charming spot is a must-visit. Indulging here is not just a treat; it's a delicious adventure!

You might also want to check out the best coffee shops in Omaha.

Olsen Bake Shop

At Olsen Bake Shop, every slice is a delightful journey into sweet bliss. Their classic apple pie boasts a perfectly flaky crust, cradling a cinnamon-spiced apple filling that dances on the palate. The homemade goodness is evident in every bite, delivering that comforting taste of nostalgia. What truly sets Olsen apart is their generous use of local ingredients, ensuring freshness that elevates the whole experience. The atmosphere is warm and inviting, making it a perfect spot for pie lovers. If you're in search of a pie that feels like a hug, Olsen Bake Shop's offerings are not to be missed!

You might also want to check out the best mexican restaurants in Omaha.

Le Quartier Bakery & Café - Dundee

At Le Quartier Bakery & Café - Dundee, the cherry pie is a true delight! The crust, a perfect balance of flaky and buttery, cradles a luscious, tart cherry filling that bursts with flavor. Each slice is like a bite of summer, brightened by a sprinkle of sugar on top. The café's inviting atmosphere adds to the experience; it’s the perfect spot to savor your pie with a cup of coffee. For pie lovers in Omaha, this place is an absolute must-visit. If you want pie that's as enchanting as its surroundings, Le Quartier has it all!

You might also want to check out the best doughnuts in Omaha.

Lithuanian Bakery & Kafe

At Lithuanian Bakery & Kafe, I was greeted with the intoxicating aroma of fresh baked goods. I couldn’t resist trying their signature cherry pie, which boasted a perfectly flaky crust that crumbles delightfully with each bite. The tart cherry filling strikes a balance between sweet and tangy, creating a flavor explosion that's both nostalgic and refreshing. It's a slice of heaven I didn’t know I needed! The cozy atmosphere and friendly staff made the experience even sweeter. If you're on the hunt for some of the best pie in Omaha, this charming gem is a must-visit. Don’t miss out!

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in West Omaha.

TOUS les JOURS

I recently indulged in TOUS les JOURS' delightful offerings, and let me tell you, their coconut cream pie is nothing short of a revelation! The crust is perfectly flaky, providing a satisfying crunch that contrasts beautifully with the luscious coconut filling. It’s not overly sweet, allowing the natural flavors to shine through. Topped with a light, airy cream that practically dances on your palate, this pie is a delightful treat. The ambiance is cozy and inviting, making it an ideal spot for pie lovers. If you're searching for a slice of happiness in Omaha, this is definitely the place to go!

You might also want to check out the best reuben sandwich in Omaha.